Wear Radar

Polar Vantage VvsGarmin vivosmart 5

Polar Vantage V
Buy/Wait:bad

Late in cycle — a new model is likely coming

Best for: Serious endurance athletes — particularly runners and triathletes — who want Polar's unmatched training load science and recovery guidance, combined with ECG health monitoring and running power in a premium package.

Full details →
Garmin vivosmart 5
Buy/Wait:bad

Overdue for a refresh — no successor announced yet. Prices should be at their lowest

Best for: Garmin users and health-focused individuals who want Body Battery, HRV, and advanced sleep analytics in a slim, discreet wristband rather than a sports watch. Compatible with both iPhone and Android via Garmin Connect.

Full details →
Polar Vantage VGarmin vivosmart 5
TierSports GPSFitness Tracker
PlatformiOS & AndroidiOS & Android
Battery8 days7 days
Always-on display
GPS
Cellular
Health sensorsecg, hr, spo2, hrv, running power, skin temphr, spo2, hrv, stress, body battery, pulse ox
ReleasedOct 4, 2023Apr 26, 2022
Cycle length1063 days700 days
Cycle advicebadbad
Deals advicegoodgood
Next modelPolar Vantage V4 (2026)

Why buy each?

Polar Vantage V

ECG on a sports GPS watch

Polar Vantage V3 is one of the few sports GPS watches with on-demand ECG — usually only found on lifestyle smartwatches.

Wrist-based running power

Running power measurement without a foot pod or chest strap — a significant training metric for pacing effort on hills and varied terrain.

Polar Training Load Pro

The most detailed training load analysis in any sports watch: muscle groups targeted per session, recovery status per muscle, and long-term load trends.

Garmin vivosmart 5

Garmin Body Battery in a band

Body Battery energy monitoring — the feature Garmin is known for — in a wristband that's thinner than most fitness trackers.

HRV status and stress tracking

Continuous heart rate variability monitoring and all-day stress tracking give a more complete picture of recovery and readiness than step counts alone.

Works with Garmin Connect ecosystem

All data syncs to Garmin Connect, compatible with thousands of third-party apps, coaches, and integrations across the Garmin platform.